One of my strengths as a pitcher was my accuracy. I can hit just about any target any time. When it would rain and practice would go into the gym sometimes we’d throw a football to build arm strength. Because throwing a ball back and forth can get boring quickly we’d find ways to have fun. One is that we’d see if we could throw the football through the basketball goal from the far end of the court. No problem. Footballs, acorns, baseballs, .22 calibre ammo, you name it. I can hit the target.
In baseball, you generally want to throw strikes and not walk batters. BUT, that’s not the most important objective for a pitcher. Ultimately, a pitcher wins when they don’t allow runs… or, allow very few runs. Looking back on my pitching days, I realize I was too focused on the little goal of throwing strikes and not the ultimate goal of not allowing runs.
The best pitchers don’t necessarily throw a lot of strikes. In fact, often the best pitches aren’t strikes. They are pitches that look like strikes but end up out of the strike zone, luring the batter to swing and miss or hit the ball poorly.
Because I threw so many strikes, batters could anticipate and trust the next pitch to be worthy of swinging at. When you eliminate that doubt, hitting becomes much easier. My senior year of college I led the team in the lowest number of walks per 9 innings. In fact, I’m still in the top 5 of all pitchers at OU over the last 25 years with that stat. BUT, my ERA was over 4. For those that don’t follow baseball, an ERA in the 2s is solid, 3s is good and 4 is mediocre at best.
I was too focused on a measure that had some value and lost focus of the measure with the most value (earned runs allowed-ERA). By the way, an example of a pitcher that I could most relate to regarding my pitching style is Greg Maddux. Crazy good control. Not high velocity. One of the best pitchers of all time. More often than not his target was outside the strike zone to get batters to swing and miss or hit the ball poorly. The biggest difference between Maddux and me wasn’t our physical ability (he looked like an accountant throwing a ball). It was our mindset. Our focus.
What measures are you focusing on? Are they the best measures or just good measures?